Log in

No account? Create an account
pinkie pie


Rich Lafferty's Journal

(mendelicious mendelusions)

Previous Entry Share Flag Next Entry
Recabling success!
kernel panic, geeky
I spent today at the FreshBooks office, reracking our network and phone switches and recabling everything properly. I'm particularly pleased with the results, so I am going to show you PHOTOS of the process.

When we moved into this office, we had about 30 people. The folks we bought the phones from did the rack cabling which was adequate. But then we started hiring more, and suddenly we had to buy another phone switch and another 48-port network switch and the cables started building up and things were getting bad. Here's our telecom/network rack as it looked first thing this morning, before I started fixing things:

FreshBooks cabling: Before

As you can see, every cable was on its own, and everything was too LONG, and some things had had to be lowered at some point so cables were coming through the wrong slot in the cable manager on the left. (The cable manager on the right was new, purchased for today's project.) You can also see that the new phone switch, right above the shelf, was pretty much unused. The new network switch was racked at the bottom of the rack, but hadn't been touched since.

So today I hand-labeled 120 or so 5' network cables, and bound them all up with seven velcro straps each into bundles of 6 -- because the patchbays at the top are grouped by six -- and rerouted every cable on there, and moved all the switches around so that the cables would have slightly longer runs and thus less folding back on themselves. But mostly it involved taking things like this:

and turning them into things like this:

But after all that reracking and recabling and labeling and bundling, I ended up with cable tray doors that close, and a rack that looks like so:

FreshBooks cabling: After!

... and 68 phone ports all of which had the wrong extension on them. But that just took a couple of trips around the office to reassign every. single. extension. on the phone switch to get things right.

But everything is cabled up now, and since the cables are all labeled by patchbay port and the switch and phone switch ports are reassignable if necessary, there shouldn't be any need to move a bunch of cables around, just adding more as we gain more capacity. (I still have 21 phone ports and probably 28 network ports left, and plans for 16 more seats in the next phase of expansion. Although now I'm thinking that it might have been better to put a phone and network switch over in the space we'd expand into and just run an uplink back to the server room, but meh.)

So I am pleased with the results given the constraints. Things I have learned for next time: Not much, really, other than to run the cables, then bundle them. Things I wish we'd done when we did the first install: leave more slack in the runs from the wall jacks to the patchbay so I could move the patchbays around. Put the switches up with the patchbays, with horizontal cable management and 1' or 3' patch cables, instead of doing the long-way-around runs we have. Buy stackable switches. (I really wish I'd bought stackable switches. I hope the inter-switch traffic isn't too much. I wonder what the backplane speed of a Linksys small-business gigabit switch is, though?)

ETA: Turns out the backplane speed of a Linksys Cisco SRW2048 such as we have is 96GB, but it also turns out that I can do link aggregation if one uplink port is insufficient. 2-4Gbps between switches ought to be plenty, I figure, if 1Gbps isn't, but I can even do up to 8 if necessary.

  • 1
The middle two images went AWOL.

Woops, silly twitpic. Fixed, thanks.

I don't think I've ever seen a customer's rack as well organised as the first picture. And you spent a Sunday doing it better!

Also : why were all the extensions wrong? Did you label the network cables after you removed them?

Re the first picture: Well, the cable management door didn't close, and none of those cables were labeled, and I had another 60 or so to add. :-)

About the extensions: Because none of the cables were labeled at all to begin with, and because I knew I could move them in software later, I concentrated on getting the cables tidy and labeled by port to begin with -- I just didn't expect that I'd end up with not one extension in the right place when I was done.

Now, the wall jacks, patchbay, and cables are all labeled with type and jack number: "V10" for the 10th voice jack along the wall, "D10" for the corresponding data one -- and those are plugged in roughly in order into the phone and data switches.

The order of the ports in the data switches doesn't matter, it's all autonegotiated gigabit, that's easy.

The phone switches are kind of weird. There's three* entities there, the physical port on the switch, the extension, and the user. So users are permanently associated with extensions (or else we'd have to reprint their business cards!), but the mapping between extension and physical port can be changed. So when all the cabling was done I went around and noted all the phones showing the wrong extension and swapped them around.

I suppose it's basically the phone equivalent of the networking burrito: phone system ports are layer 2, extensions are layer 3, and I guess users are equivalent to hostnames.

It wasn't that much work in the end, really: one trip around to write down "Sunir has 240" etc., then going through the extension list on the phone system to see "Sunir should have 228" and "Sunir is on port 112", then one big run through the extension config panel making sure 228 was on port 112 etc., then a reboot** and another trip around the room to make sure I didn't miss any.

* Well, four: the phones hot-desk, too, so you can bring your extension/user up on any phone. But the phones have a default extension which is what comes up after a reboot, so I had to get that right.

** Not actually required, but a reboot un-hot-desks everyone, and otherwise the phones would have required everyone to log themselves back in tomorrow morning.

More answer then I expected. And yes, neat racks are their own reward.

> phone system ports are layer 2, extensions are layer 3, and I guess users are equivalent to hostnames.

One diff that I wasn't aware of is that while a computer keeps its IP when it changes ports, the phones don't seem to. Which makes sense for phones.

These ones, yeah. Nortel PBXes are configurable that way -- extension-follows-phone or extension-follows-port. That sounds handy but it's sufficiently not what people expect that the surprises aren't worth the benefits.

Network Cable management

This comprehensive product offering addresses power, cooling, space and cable management challenges, Network Cable management enabling reduced energy consumption, enhanced network reliability, and optimized space utilization.

Cable Organizer frame manufactured out of steel sheet punched, formed, Cable rack Management welded and powder coated and Doors made of aluminum sheet punched formed and powder coated with highest quality standards under stringent ISO 9001-2008 Manufacturing & Quality management system to ensure highest quality product. NetRack Encl

Channel type cable management rack manufactured out of Rigid PVC with punched side slots for cable entry/ exit fixed on Steel sheet punched Back panel and Loop Type will have ABS Loops fixed on steel sheetp punched back Panel with highest quality standards under stringent ISO 9001-2008 Manufacturing & Quality management system to ensure highest quality product.

  • 1